Fishing for Answers II – How Brexit Can Disrupt the UK Seafood Trade
The UK has more to lose than the EU if a tariff is imposed on EU–UK seafood trade following the Brexit transition period. While the transition agreement is expected to ensure free trade through to the end of 2020, tariffs could be introduced between the EU and the UK from 2021 onwards, depending on the outcome of the Brexit negotiations. Imposition of a tariff would hinder the UK’s seafood trade flows more than those of the EU.
What the UK catches is not what the UK eats
The UK exports most of its seafood catch, and what is consumed in the domestic market is mainly imported. Mackerel, langoustine, and scallops are the top three species caught in British waters by British vessels, but they don’t have a market in the UK. These species are exported, predominantly to the EU. On the other hand, cod, haddock, pollock, as well as shrimp and prawns are the species favoured most by British consumers – yet they are largely imported. Salmon is quite different. Two-thirds of the salmon produced in the UK is exported – some 105.000 tonnes – while salmon imports are about half the size of what is produced locally.
UK seafood trade flows are asymmetric
The EU is more important as a market for the UK’s seafood exports than as a source of its imports. Currently, 70% of the UK’s (shell)fish exports are shipped to the EU (see Figure 1), while British seafood imports come from more diverse sources. The EU supplies more than 30% of the UK’s seafood imports. Another 20% of UK seafood imports come from other non-EU Western European countries with whom the EU has a preferential trade agreement, such as the Faroe Islands, Iceland, and Norway.
Figure 1: The UK’s heavy dependency on the EU for seafood exports is not reflected in its seafood imports
The UK’s key seafood exports, namely, salmon, scallops, langoustine, mackerel, shrimp and prawns are largely exported to the EU member states. Of these species, only salmon has a significant market outside the EU, with around 17% of production being exported to the US. Salmon, followed by cod, also has the highest value in British seafood imports. Both species are largely supplied from the non-EU Western European countries and the EU.
Tariffs could hinder the UK’s seafood trade flows more than the EU’s
Introducing tariffs on seafood trade flows between the isles and the mainland would hamper UK seafood trade more than EU seafood trade. If tariffs make the UK uncompetitive in exporting to the EU, the UK might have difficulties in finding new export markets for its seafood products, while the damage of tariff imposition on the EU would be more limited, as the EU can divert its seafood exports to other regions more easily. Moreover, UK seafood imports would become more expensive if the UK doesn’t sign a free trade agreement (FTA) with the EU and other non-EU Western European countries.
The EU and the UK agreed on a Brexit transition agreement on 19 March 2018, which is expected to ensure free trade until 31 December 2020. However, the transition agreement is not yet legally binding. Although Rabobank expects a transition period through to the end of 2020, followed by an FTA, a hard Brexit still remains possible.1 In the case of an FTA, the terms of future trade will be subject to negotiations. Some seafood products might still be subject to tariffs under an FTA, as preferential agreements could have exemptions for certain products, or some products could still be protected by tariff quotas.
Seafood trade tariffs could be as high as 20%
In most trade negotiations, the starting point is the so-called Most-Favoured-Nation (MFN) tariff rates, which are normal non-discriminatory tariffs established by the WTO. The EU’s MFN tariff rates that could apply to seafood products imported from the UK range from 2% to 20%. If tariffs are imposed, salmon trade flows would be least affected, as MFN tariffs on the EU’s Atlantic salmon imports are relatively low at 2%. If, on the other hand, the EU imposes MFN tariffs on other key British seafood export products like scallops, langoustine, shrimp and prawns, this could hinder the UK’s exports to the EU considerably, as the EU’s MFN tariffs range from 8% to 20% on these species. Currently, the UK benefits from tariff-free cod imports from the EU and other non-EU western European countries. Following Brexit, the future tariffs on the UK’s cod imports would depend on whether the UK signs FTAs with the EU and third countries. In case of a hard Brexit, tariffs would be defined by the UK under WTO rules. The EU’s MFN tariffs on cod imports range from 7,5% to 18%.
To maintain no or low-tariff seafood trade following Brexit, the UK might need to negotiate an FTA not only with the EU, but also with the Faroe Islands, Iceland, and Norway. Tariffs are one factor adding ‘friction’ to trade. However, with the introduction of borders, in a post-Brexit world, non-tariff barriers such as food safety measures and customs clearance procedures could also create friction for the EU-UK seafood trade.
1 For more information please see Brexit update: transition ON! by Alexandra Dumitru and Stefan Koopman
Download a PDF version of this article
Where to go from here
Beyhan de JongAnalyst – Animal Protein Read more